1 Zulugul

The Trolley Dodgers Case Study

Trolley Dodgers case QUESTIONS 1. Identify the key audit objectives for a client’s payroll function. Comment on both objectives related to tests of controls and those related to substantive audit procedures. Answer: The key audit objectives are occurrence and existence, completeness, accuracy, posting & summarization, presentation and disclosure, timing and classification. Because “completeness” objectives means there is a need to check all of the amounts paid to employees when the big amounts involved in the payroll, so, for a client’s payroll function, in this situation, “completeness” objectives should be considered. Auditors should level the control risk on all payroll transection cycle which is auditors’ major objective on performing tests of controls. In order to determine the nature, extent, and timing of the year-end substantive tests auditors need to assess control risk for a transaction cycle to get strong evidences. A payroll transaction cycle has two key accounts which are accrued payrolls and

Similar Documents

Trolley Problems

...Problem 1 of the Trolley problems talks about a runaway trolley that will surely kill 5 people on the track. The person reading is put in a position where he has immediate access to a switch that can divert this runaway trolley but doing so will kill one person on that side track. Problem 2 puts the person reading on a bridge over the tracks next to a very large person who. We are given the chose to push the very large person on the track which will stop the runaway trolley, thereby saving the life of 5 people on the track ahead but taking the life of the large person used to stop the trolley. Both questions ask will the person reading choose to kill the 1 person on the side-track or the large man on the bridge to save the lives of 5 more. According to Kantian ethics a person may believe good will acts for the sake of moral duty thereby giving the act itself moral worth. As long as the action then is driven by a sense of duty to do something good for others, even for strangers, then it is ethical. If the person chooses to turn on the switch to save the 5 lives and sacrifice the 1, as long as he believes that saving the lives of 5 people and sacrificing the life of 1 for them, with him being the factor that ends the life of that 1 and he stands beside his action, then from a Kantian perspective, the act has moral worth. This is the same for Problem 2, if the person is willing to push the large man on the tracks, is willing to take the life of that man to save the life of 5,......

Words: 735 - Pages: 3

Case 3-1 Dodgers Trolley

...1. Identify the key audit objectives for a client’s payroll function. Comment on both objectives related to tests of control and those related to tests of control s and those related to substantive audit procedure. The key audit objectives for client’s payroll function in this Trolley Dodgers Case are: * Occurrence-establish whether employees worked * Completeness-make sure hours are recorded * Accuracy-make sure hours work and salary paid are correct * Posting & Summarization-compare payroll master with general ledger * Classification –establish identity for each employee and correct pay rate * Timing-verify whether payroll was issued efficiently Payroll frauds do not take place as much as it used to, that does not mean it will not occur. Fraudulent activities such as fabricated employees, overpaying employees, and continuing employees on payroll after they have left the company are a risk. That is why a well-built internal control of payroll is needed. Test of controls consist of making sure that employees worked, by comparing payroll with hours worked and salary paid. Employees should have correct withholding taxes taken out and paid at the appointed time without error. Strong internal control require that the adding and taking away of names from the company payroll as well as pay rate changes and reclassification of employees be witnessed in writing by an executive in the Human Resources department and by management of the department......

Words: 505 - Pages: 3

3.1case 3.1 the Trolley Dodgers

...CASE 3.1 THE TROLLEY DODGERS In 1890, the Brooklyn Trolley Dodgers professional baseball team joined the National League. Over the following years, the Dodgers would have considerable difficulty competing with the other baseball teams in the New York City area. Those teams, principal among them the New York Yankees, were much better financed and generally stocked with players of higher caliber. In 1958, after nearly seven decades of mostly frustration on and off the baseball field, the Dodgers shocked the sports world by moving to Los Angeles. Walter O’Malley, the flamboyant owner of the Dodgers, saw an opportunity to introduce professional baseball to the rapidly growing population of the West Coast. More important, O’Malley saw an opportunity to make his team more profitable. As an inducement to the Dodgers, Los Angeles County purchased a goat farm located in Chavez Ravine, an area two miles northwest of downtown Los Angeles, and gave the property to O’Malley for the site of his new baseball stadium. Since moving to Los Angeles, the Dodgers have been the envy of the baseball world: “In everything from profit to stadium maintenance . . . the Dodgers are the prototype of how a franchise should be run.”1 During the 1980s, the Dodgers reigned as the most profitable franchise in baseball with a pre-tax profit margin approaching 25 percent in many years. In late 1997, Peter O’Malley, Walter O’- Malley’s son and the Dodgers’ principal owner, sold the franchise for $350......

Words: 740 - Pages: 3

Case Study Trolley

...CASE STUDY: THE TROLLEY DODGERS 1. Identify the key audit objectives for a client’s payroll function. Comment on both objectives related to tests of control and those related to tests of control s and those related to substantive audit procedure. The key audit objectives for client’s payroll function in this Trolley Dodgers Case are: i. Occurrence  ii. Completeness iii. Accuracy iv. Posting & Summarization v. Classification  vi. Timing i. Key Audit Objective : Occurrence Dodgers must recorded payroll payments for existing employees only and should have separation of duties for each task. Test of Control: Examine internal control to see if the payroll payments are for exiting work and existing employees. The test could be examining all the workers time cards, personnel files and review organization chart. They also can discuss with employees and observe duties being performed. The tests would examine printouts of transactions rejected by the computer as having nonexistent employee numbers. Substantive Test of Transactions: The test to see if the right dollar amount in the payrolls were recorded and paid properly. They also test to review large dollar amount in the journal entries, general ledger and payroll earnings. Examine cancelled checks for proper endorsement could be compare with a personnel record. ii. Key Audit Objective : Completeness Dodgers must record all existent payroll transactions. Test of Control: The test is to see if the......

Words: 1039 - Pages: 5

Case 3.1 the Trolley Dodgers

...Case 3.1 The Trolley Dodgers 1. The key audit objectives for a clients payroll function are a. Occurrence and existence, b. Completeness, c. Accuracy, d. Posting & summarization, e. Presentation and disclosure, f. Timing and classification. The objective of completeness requires checking all of the amounts paid to the employees to see if they are correct and paid in full. Auditors should level the control risk on all payroll transaction cycle, which is auditor’s major objective on performing tests of controls. In order to determine the nature, extent, and timing of the year-end substantive tests, auditors need to assess control risk for a transaction cycle to get strong evidences. A payroll transaction cycle has two key accounts, which are accrued payroll and payroll expenses. Auditors mainly are concerned of these two accounts violating the completeness objective for most expense and liability accounts. Auditors should use comprehensive analytical procedures when assessing periodic payroll expense to check its rationality. After checking the payroll expense and considering it with the recent average employee pay raise, auditors will develop an expectation. If the payroll expense provided by the clients is out of the auditors expectation, then, substantive procedures and are tests needed to further check those differences. 2. There are several internal control weaknesses in the Dodgers payroll system: ......

Words: 381 - Pages: 2

Big Brother Case 3.1

...Big Brother Case 3.1 Business Ethics and Social Repsonsibility OMM640 November 17, 2012 Big Brother Case 3.1 Has there ever been a time when you were so ecstatic about your new job opportunity that you just simply signed your life away? How many times has a individual actually carefully read each word in each sentence of every paragraph on the countless pages before signing on the dotted line or initially on the page and signing on the very last page. Many employees may lightly read the material read the bold point or like me read over quickly and try to see if there is any fine print that will draw my attention. In any case the information on the page is what the company offers and what it expects from their employees. Some documentation may state that you are revoking your rights to work for any competing companies or that you have to adhere to the confidentiality of the organization under any circumstance permitted by law. It is not an abuse of power when one signs that they will be in compliance with the rules and regulations of the company in whom they are employed by. Yet is an abuse of power when they perform analytical searches into phone records of each resident in the 513 and 606 area codes as well as the phone records of 803, 849 homes (Boatright, 2009, p. 61). This is were P&G fell off and became erroneous. Verifying phone records of P&G employees would have been rationalized if and only if the company stayed within their limits.......

Words: 568 - Pages: 3

Case 3.1 a Day in the Life of Brent Dorsey

...Deana Chamberlain Case 1 ACC 416 Seminar Two Case 3.1 1. What alternatives are available to Brent in regards to the audit of payables? What are the pros and cons of each alternative? Brent and Han could pull twenty invoices rather than thirty invoices and go against the audit plan. Since the account payables haven’t shown any problems in the last few years, chances are there won’t be any problems this year. Doing this they could save at least a third of the time and possibly meet the deadline. The problem with doing this is that it goes against the audit plan and potential be an issue if there did end up being a problem this year. They could just do the audit of the account payables and say that it only took the 35 hours regardless of the amount of time it really takes. Doing this would bring the audit in under budget and John would be happy with this and it would look good on the upcoming performance evaluations. This would be helpful in their promotions to senior auditors. The problem with this if they accomplish the audit in this time frame they will be expected to do it again next year. 2. What consequences for Brent, the auditing firm, and others involved, may arise from “eating time” as Han suggested? Similarly, what consequences for Brent, the auditing firm, and others involved, may arise from not completing audit procedures, as Megan suggested? As mentioned above, “eating time” may look good now, but in the future they will be...

Words: 926 - Pages: 4

Trolley Dodgers Case

...The Trolley Dodgers 1) It is the auditor’s objective to determine if management’s assertions are materially complete, valid and accurate. Auditors have various procedures and testing to achieve their objectives. The test of controls is used to determine the reliability of the financial statements by identifying the existence of internal controls, so it is important to understand how inaccuracies within the payroll system would affect accounts on the balance sheet and income statement. Wages are recorded as an expense on the income statement, so they reduce net income. In this Trolley Dodgers case, wages were being fraudulently inflated, so the affect would be understatement of net income on the income statement. Wages are also an accrued expense that require an adjusting entry; the wage amount would be recorded as a current liability on the balance sheet and an accrued expense on the income statement. Again, if wages are being fraudulently inflated, the current liabilities on the balance sheet would also be inflated and the overall result is a misrepresentation of the client’s performance on the financial statements. If it has been determined that the internal controls are ineffective, substantive testing is then necessary to verify accuracy of the dollar amounts. This is a more in-depth and analytical testing to verify the figures the client has provided. Auditors must test management’s assertions about account balances as they are reflected on the balance sheet. When......

Words: 1125 - Pages: 5

Case 3.1 a Scandinavian Scare

...CASE 3.1 A SCANDINAVIAN SCARE Discussion Questions 1. Why did Conquip send an RFQ with a 10 percent price-reduction requirement rather than calling de Winter in for negotiation? Is there any downside to having run the negotiation this way? Conquip was trying to give a time pressure to FD. This can be seen when Conquip sent the RFP (Request for Quote) to FD regarding the product, LEIF filter, which still not even widely adopted by Conquip. This particular pressure functions as an external constraint to FD. Conceptually, the constraint removes what could be the most attractive of options for FD to continue to negotiate in an effort to improve the terms of the agreement. Lacking this option leads FD to face with a twofold choice which they can either agree or refuse the agreement requested by Conquip. This could appear like a great strategy until Conquip realise that there's no difference between that and FD might also putting on time pressure to them. There could be a situation in which both sides are approaching the same time deadline. And in this particular case, the one that has the greatest power is the one with more alternatives who could use time pressure, but the side with fewer alternatives has the least power should avoid time pressure and negotiate well before the deadline. 2. At the first negotiation meeting, Conquip made a threat disguised within an offer. The offer was to retain FD as a companywide, primary supplier if FD could meet its price demands....

Words: 840 - Pages: 4

Case 3.1

...Case 5.1 Junjie Chen 1.Intergrity and Ethical Values 5 Simply steam Co is in an industry has lots of employees’ turnover. So we cannot say they have a very strong integrity of management and employees. But they do put some effort to monitoring the company, Phil is always in charge of employees and give them appropriate training. That do helps build the team. 2, Board of Directors 4 They are kind of a family and close friends based company, so they don’t have audit committee. Also, they are not independent of management. They also join to the day-to-day business. The good thing is they are very familiar with their job and corporate well. So for this size of business, its management is effective. 3. Management’s Philosophy and Operating Style 6 Open door policy help employees say what they see when some unfavorable things happen. They have the willing to be audited reveals that they want to pursue their business endeavors in future and want more professional ideas about how to prepare their financial statement. This attitude also means they want to control the uncertain risk in their company. 4. Organizational Structure 5 Phil takes care of employees training. Mr. Day as the office manager assigning of daily duties and overview of each day’s accounting records. Sometimes may have overlapping of duties because they assign works based on who are available. Buy overall, they I don’t think they have a need to hire an extra accountant to......

Words: 576 - Pages: 3

Case 3.1 La Dodgers

...function is to test management’s assertions about timekeeping, paycheck processing, record keeping, employee benefits and pay distribution. The assertions about payroll that would be tested here are occurrence, existence, completeness, authorization, and accuracy. The objective of testing controls is to make sure that the company’s controls sufficiently address the risks of misstatement that could occur. The objective of substantive audit procedures is to detect material misstatements in a transaction class, account balance, or disclosure component of the financial statements. (Messier 2014) (Messier, William. Auditing and Assurance Services. McGraw Hill, New York, NY. 2012. Print.) 2. What internal control weaknesses were evident in the Dodgers’ payroll system? Control Weaknesses * No separation of duties such as the person writing the checks and the person keeping the books – Campos kept the books and wrote the checks * Control environment and tone at the top was inadequate – collusion among employees helped Campos succeed in his scheme. * Inadequate documentation of the components of internal control – it was a system only he fully understood. 3. Identify audit procedures that might have led to the discovery of the fraudulent scheme masterminded by Campos. Inspection: Close inspection of payroll by an auditor would probably show that weekly paychecks were unusually large. Here you would want to make sure that original timecards match payroll entry......

Words: 331 - Pages: 2

Audit Case 3.1

...Case 3.1 1. Brent has many alternatives. The first alternative Brent has is to eat the time. The pro of eating time is that he gets the work done and helps his team out without any problems. The con of eating time is that he cannot spend time with his wife. Also, this could lead to the firm and company believing that the time granted for the audit is acceptable and put pressure on future staff auditors. A second option Brent has is to quit the firm. The pro of this would be that Brent could not have to deal with the long hours and spend more time with his wife. The con of this decision is that it does not look good to quit a job very early and he would have to find a different job to provide income for his family. A third option would be for Brent to not take as many invoices when performing the audit. The pro of this choice is that Brent would finish the audit on time and the con is that this leaves rooms for mistakes which could be very costly. The final option Brent has is to speak with the manager about the time allotted to the audit. The pro of this choice is that maybe the manager will understand and grant Brent more time. The con to this choice is that Brent is new to the job and should be willing to do what he needs to do to help the team out. 2. If Brent decides to “eat time” there would be many consequences for him and the firm. Brent would have to buckle up and forget about spending time with his wife over the weekend and risk her being very upset.......

Words: 568 - Pages: 3

Case 3.1

...Baltimore instead of Washington’s Dulles or Reagan)   3. In 2004, Southwest hedged about 85% of its fuel and oil needs and as a result saved about $455 million.   4. Southwest pilot did not belong to a National Union. Therefore they’re not limited by... View Full Essay Join Now Please login to view the full essay... Essay's StatisticsSubmitted by: dhianparamitaDate shared: 12/11/2014 07:31 AMWords: 1043Pages: 5 Save PaperReport this Essay Similar DocumentsSouthwest Airlines CorporationSouthwest Airlines CorporationSouthwest Airline CorporationSouthwest Airlines CorporationSouthwest AirlinesSouthwest AirlinesDiversification Strategies: The Secret Of Southwest Airlines" SuccessSouthwest Airlines Case StudyThe Origanal Southwest AirlinesSouthwest Airlines Case StudyHr Analysis In Southwest AirlineSouthwest AirlinesSouthwest AirlinesSouthwest AirlinesSouthwest Airlines Motivational ProfileSouthwest AirlineAn Analysis Of “Southwest Airlines: We Love Your Bags”Southwest AirlinesSouthwest Airlines Organizational BehaviorSouthwest Airlines LoginJoin RSS ©2015 TermPaperWarehouse.com Privacy Policy Terms of Service Copyright Information Contact Us Help Advertise With Us...

Words: 383 - Pages: 2

Case 3.1 Brief

...------------------------------------------------- PREPARING A CASE BRIEF FOR CASE 3.1 ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- Lindgren v GDT, LLC ------------------------------------------------- 312 F.Supp.2d 1125 (S.D. Iowa 2004) ------------------------------------------------- Jangling Jewels on the Internet: Can the Court Loop Them In? ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------- GM520: Legal, Political, and Ethical Dimensions ------------------------------------------------- CASE BRIEF: CASE 3.1 Case Name: Lindgren v GDT, LLC Case Citation: Lindgren v GDT, LLC312 F.Supp.2d 1125 (S.D. Iowa 2004) Procedural History: Ms. Lindgren filed suit in federal district court in Iowa against GDT for infringement. Ms. Lindgren says that GDT has a Web site and is selling its jewels to residents in Iowa and must come to Iowa to defend a suit because it is doing business there. GDT filed a motion to dismiss the case for lack......

Words: 1437 - Pages: 6

Dodgers Case 3.1

...Case 3.1 Jessica Kelley-Seamans Acc-412 1- Identify the key objectives for a client’s payroll function. Comment on objectives related to tests of controls and substantive audit procedures. The payroll functions include * employment ( HR) * timekeeping * payroll preparation and recordkeeping * Pay distribution (Whitman, pg 626) Each of these payroll actions should be kept separate from one another, in accordance with proper segregation of duties. Segregation of duties can be described as the separation of related procedures that will prevent employees and officers from committing fraud. The duties that should be kept separate are authorization, record keeping, and custody. According to the AICPA,” no single individual should be able to (1) authorize a transaction, (2) record the transaction in the accounting records, and (3) maintain custody of the assets resulting from the transaction”( Members in Government Guide to Internal control, pg 10). The key objectives for a client’s payroll function are * Occurrence and existence * Accuracy * Completeness * Presentation and disclosures (Key Audit Objectives for a Client's Payroll Function). I will now go over each objective, and discuss the related tests of controls and substantive audit procedures. Just too quickly review, tests of controls focus on the functionality of the controls themselves, and substantive procedures focus on direct verification of the output of the......

Words: 1918 - Pages: 8

Leave a Comment


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *