1 Samugami

Movie Vs Book Essay

Compare and Contrast: Movies vs. Books


When you ask people whether they prefer 'Movies or Books', you are likely to get a variety of replies. Some people will prefer reading books and other will prefer watching movies. There is another interesting phenomena and that is a section of the population that enjoy both equally.


For some people, reading a book is not the easiest activity in the world. We have all sometimes picked up a book and put it down after battling to read the first page. This is nothing to do with ability or concentration, it is to do with whether or not the book is of personal interest or whether the book actually meets our needs. In other words what is inside the covers of the book may not match the blurb on the outside which is very misleading and very disappointing. The same can be said for movies. How often have we all watched the trailers advertised on TV, thinking that the movie looks really interesting? Then follows the anticipation of going to the movies to watch it, or wait until its available to download and rent at home, only to watch the first ten minutes and realise that it is not going to get any better than 'boring'!

Sometimes it is easier to watch a movie rather than read the book. Some movies that are adaptations of books can enhance the setting, the scenery and dialogue. This is especially helpful for people who have experienced difficulty in learning to read, as watching the movie as well as reading the book can enhance the experience. A movie adaptation can enhance the experience of the book and can bring to life, and get transported into 'this other world'. Visual images are very powerful, but so is the experience of reading and development of our own images. It can also be argued that in order to use our imagination whilst reading we need to have some actual experience of the situation and that experience either comes through accurate and informative writing or visual images (movies).

There are several books that have been made into movies. The interpretation of a book into a movie is bound by resources and finance, and the visualisation of the director. Meanwhile reading the book, taps into the readers imagination, that does not have the same constraints and can be picked and put down at any convenient time.

Essay/Term paper: The pit and the pendulum: movie vs. book

Essay, term paper, research paper:  Movie Reviews

See all college papers and term papers on Movie Reviews

Need a different (custom) essay on Movie Reviews? Buy a custom essay on Movie Reviews

Need a custom research paper on Movie Reviews? Click here to buy a custom term paper.

The Pit and the Pendulum: Movie vs. Book

The movie "The pit and the Pendulum" was nothing at all like the book. The
movie started out as a man walked along the ocean to enter a huge castle. His
sister had moved there when she married Dom Madena, but now she was dead. The
castle was used to torture Catholics during the Inquisition. Dom Madena
believes that the castle has an atmosphere of torture thick with death, and that
led to the death of his sister. The doctor said she died of fright. They
buried her in a tomb below the castle.
As child Dom Madena saw his father torture and kill his father's brother
and his own wife. He accused them of adultery. His father didn't torture his
mother to death, he buried her alive. Dom Madena thought that he buried his
wife alive. Then one night someone was playing the harpsichord just like his
wife did. Another time a servant heard his wife whispering to her. Then one
night someone trashed her room.
Dom Madena, also called Nicholas, heard his wife calling him. He went
through a secret passageway until he entered the room of all the torturing
devices. He goes to his wife grave, which they dug up to prove she was dead,
and she popped out of her grave. She chased him through the dungeon until they
met with the doctor. Then Nicholas fainted, and his wife, who never really died,
told him that it was all scheme. She and the doctor were having an affair. He
chased the doctor and he fell into a pit and died. He stuck his wife in a
torture machine out of sight and gagged her.
Then her brother came down. Nicholas seized him and put him on table
below a razor sharp pendulum. Right as it was cutting his shirt two servants
busted in and threw Nicholas into the pit with the doctor and saved him.
This movie, I think anyway, was a very poor interpretation of the short
story. In the story none every commits adultery or is buried alive. A man, or
woman for all I know, was stuck in a dungeon which he was tortured in many ways.
None died in the book, but in the movie three people died. The book had one
character where the movie had seven or eight. The story line in the book of a
suffering catholic being tortured to death was altered to make a script for a
movie. The only likeness was when the two men were almost killed by the falling
pendulum, but saved at the last minute either by others or themselves. In the
end of the book the walls of iron are heated and start to push together. But
right before the person dies a French general grabs him because Toledo was just
taken by the French.
The pit in the book was a hole in the middle of the cell. The captive
almost fell in it when the room was pitch black. When the walls were caving in
he could of chose the pit or the hot iron walls. The pit is supposed to be the
ultimate death in the dungeon and the captive doesn't want to die in it.
The movie and the story were so different that if I watched the movie
and read the story without knowing the name of either I would say they had
nothing at all in common. I definitely wouldn't know they were written by the
same author.


Other sample model essays:

World Literature / Creative Writing: The Present

Creative Writing: The Present Theme: Greed and stupidity. "Mysterious Fires Breaking out Across Prince Rupert, British Colombia"-- John Reeves "I can't believe there is another...

World Literature / Creative Writing: The Quest

Creative Writing: The Quest Feeling quite tired and hungry, my friend and I entered the food court of the Everett Mall. Looking around, I decided that I was going to get some Chinese food...

World Literature / The Real Sucker

The Real Sucker Geoff Karanasos CARSON McCULLERS December 12, 1996 Many Different experiences in a child's life help form the personality and attitude he or she will adopt later in life. ...

World Literature / The Masque Of The Red Death: The Red Death Vs. AIDs

The Masque of The Red Death: The Red Death Vs. AIDs If I were to compare "The Masque of the Red Death" to a movie, I would compare it to the HBO special on aids, "And The Band Played On". Bo...

World Literature / The Satire Of Jonathan Swift Revealed

The Satire of Jonathan Swift Revealed During the eighteenth century there was an incredible upheaval of commercialization in London, England. As a result, English society underwent si...

The Scarlet Letter / The Scarlet Letter: The Scaffold's Power

The Scarlet Letter: The Scaffold's Power Recurring events show great significance and elucidate the truth beneath appearances. In The Scarlet Letter Nathaniel Hawthorne chooses the sc...

The Scarlet Letter / The Scarlet Letter: Review

The Scarlet Letter: Review Adultery, betrayal, promiscuity, subterfuge, and intrigue, all of which would make an excellent coming attraction on the Hollywood scene and probably a pr...

World Literature / Creative Writing: The Search

Creative Writing: The Search I used to work for the F.B.I., in the Portland office. It was my childhood dream to be the one who gets the bad guy. My fiftieth birthday was in just thr...

World Literature / The Shining

The Shining The story take place in Colorado and begins with Jack Torrence, going to a place by the name of "The Overlook Hotel" to be the caretaker over the winter month's, because of coast ...

Ernest Hemingway / The Short Happy Life Of Francis Macomber

The Short Happy Life of Francis Macomber English 102 Essay #1 In Ernest Hemingway's story, "The Short Happy Life of Francis Macomber," Francis Macomber, according to Hemingway, is a v...

Leave a Comment


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *